Dealer vs Third-Party Car Warranty: Making the Right Choice

Did you know that 55% of car owners face unexpected repair costs within the first five years of owning a vehicle? Choosing the right extended car warranty is key. It helps protect your investment and lowers costs. With dealership and third-party choices, which one is best for you? We'll explore the good and bad points of each. This way, you can make a smart choice.

Key Takeaways:

- Compare dealership and third-party extended car warranty plans to get the best for your car.
- When deciding, think about the coverage, duration, and reputation of the companies.
- By looking at these details, you can choose the right extended warranty for your needs.

What is an Extended Car Warranty?

An extended car warranty gives your vehicle more protection. It goes past what the maker’s warranty does. This means extra peace of mind for you.

Dealer vs Manufacturer Extended Car Warranties

Check your car loan repayments
Use our FREE calculator

Choosing a warranty for your car involves considering a dealer-extended warranty or a manufacturer-extended warranty. Each has unique benefits and things to think about.

Dealer-extended warranties are from the car's dealership. They might need you to service your car only there. This ensures experts work on your car. But it limits where you can service your car. Also, it could cost more to service your car under this warranty.

Manufacturer-extended warranties come directly from the car maker. They often let you service your car more freely. They can be used at various service places. If you sell your car, the warranty could stay with it. This can be more useful if you move or have a trusted local mechanic.

When choosing between dealer and manufacturer warranties, see the warranty restrictions and servicing limitations of each. Remember, the warranty could affect your car's resale value. Also, think about the servicing costs for each plan. Considering these factors will help you make the best choice for your situation.

Extended Warranties and Car Servicing

Extended warranties protect your car beyond the usual guarantee. They keep you safe from surprise repair costs. This way, owning a car becomes less stressful.

Dealerships might say you must service your car there for your warranty to be valid. But, that's not true. Getting your car serviced somewhere else can save you money. You are free to pick a mechanic or service centre that fits your budget and needs.

Picking the right extended warranty means looking at all the servicing costs. This ensures you don't spend more than you've planned. It's smart to think about costs like maintenance and repairs from the start.

Extended warranties combined with independent servicing are a great match. They offer peace of mind, save you money, and boost your car's selling price. So, whether your car is new or older, consider getting an extended warranty.

How to Keep Your Car Manufacturer's Warranty Intact

Get your lowest rate from 30+ lenders

Buying a new car often comes with the excitement of having a reliable vehicle backed by a factory warranty. Car manufacturers offer these warranties to ensure your vehicle remains protected against defects and certain repairs for a specific period. However, to keep the warranty intact, it's crucial to understand the warranty terms and follow specific guidelines. Here's how to maintain your car warranty:

1. Adhere to the Maintenance Schedule: Car warranties typically require you to get your vehicle serviced regularly. This includes routine maintenance such as oil changes, tyre rotations, and inspections. Ensure your vehicle receives timely service, either at the dealership or a third-party provider. Many warranty claims are denied because the owner failed to follow the prescribed maintenance schedule.

2. Use Authorised Repair Services: To avoid voiding the warranty, it's essential to use authorised repair services. Warranties generally stipulate that you should take your car to an authorised dealer for repairs. Car warranties and dealer servicing go hand in hand, as unauthorised repairs may not be worth the risk of voiding the warranty.

3. Keep Detailed Records: Maintain detailed records of all services and repairs performed on your vehicle. This includes receipts and service logs. If a warranty claim arises, these records can prove that you’ve adhered to the warranty terms, preventing any disputes with the car warranty companies.

4. Avoid Unauthorised Modifications: Modifying your car with aftermarket parts can void its warranty. Car manufacturers often specify which modifications are acceptable. Before making any changes, review the warranty coverage to ensure you're not inadvertently voiding it.

5. Understand What’s Covered and What’s Not: Warranties are generally comprehensive but not all-encompassing. Powertrain warranties, for example, cover the engine and transmission but may exclude other components. Familiarise yourself with what the original factory warranty covers and what it doesn’t to avoid unexpected costs.

6. Consider an Extended Warranty: If you plan to keep the vehicle for an extended period, consider purchasing an extended warranty. The best-extended car warranty options offer additional coverage beyond the new car warranty. Dealer warranties typically provide this, but you can also explore extended warranty offers from third-party providers.

7. Stay Within Mileage Limits: New cars typically come with mileage limits under their warranty terms. Exceeding these limits can void the warranty. Keep track of your vehicle’s mileage to ensure it stays within the allowed range.

8. Watch Out for Exclusions: Certain conditions, such as neglect or misuse, can void the warranty. Ensure your vehicle is operated according to the manufacturer's guidelines. Car warranties generally exclude coverage for damage caused by accidents, natural disasters, or misuse.

By following these guidelines, you can maintain your car's manufacturer warranty and enjoy peace of mind knowing that your vehicle is covered. Whether you're dealing with the warranty from the dealership or exploring a vehicle service contract from a third-party provider, understanding and adhering to the warranty terms is crucial to keeping your motor vehicle protected.

Extended Warranties for Used Cars: Choosing the Best Extended Car Warranty

When it comes to purchasing a used car, understanding the ins and outs of extended warranties and vehicle service contracts is crucial for ensuring a smooth and worry-free ownership experience.

Car Finance Considerations: Before diving into the realm of extended warranties, consider your car finance options. Many car dealerships offer attractive financing deals that may include extended warranties as part of the package. This can be a convenient and cost-effective way to protect your investment, especially if the vehicle's age or warranty costs are a concern.

Assessing the Age of the Vehicle: One of the first steps in choosing the best vehicle service contract is to assess the age of the vehicle. Older cars may require more frequent repairs, making an extended warranty a wise investment. On the other hand, newer cars may still benefit from extended warranties to safeguard against unexpected costs.

Comparing Warranty Costs: Take the time to compare warranty costs from different providers. While warranties often come with a price tag, the peace of mind and potential savings from covered repairs are also worth considering. Some dealerships may offer competitive pricing on extended warranties, while third-party providers may provide more flexibility in coverage options.

Dealer vs. Third-Party Options: Evaluate both dealer and third-party options when it comes to extended warranties. Dealer warranties may come with certain advantages, such as ease of service at the dealership and potential value-added services. However, third-party warranties can offer more flexibility in terms of coverage and may be more cost-effective in some cases.

Considering New or Used: Whether you're purchasing a new or used car, exploring extended warranty options is a prudent decision. New cars may come with manufacturer warranties, but extending coverage can provide additional peace of mind as the vehicle ages. For used cars, a comprehensive vehicle service contract can protect against unforeseen repair costs.

Exploring Car Dealerships: Don't overlook the benefits of exploring extended warranties through car dealerships. Many dealers offer comprehensive warranty packages that cover a range of repairs and services, tailored to both new and used vehicles.

By considering these factors and choosing the best vehicle service contract for your needs, you can enjoy peace of mind on the road, knowing that unexpected repair costs are covered and your investment is protected.


It's vital to be well-informed when picking a car's extended warranty. Think about what the warranty covers, who provides it, and the provider's standing.

Dealership warranties are easy and can add value when you sell the car. But, they could tie you down and make servicing more expensive. Third-party warranties give you more freedom and might save you money on servicing. Yet, they could cover less.

Think about your priorities, like ease, keeping your car's value up, or saving on repair costs. There's a warranty that fits your needs. Do your homework, compare, and choose wisely.

How Driva Can Help You Finance Your Next Vehicle Purchase

Driva offers a range of services to help you finance your next vehicle purchase and ensure you are covered in case of unexpected expenses. When purchasing a new car from a car manufacturer, the warranty may provide peace of mind against any potential issues during the warranty period. However, it's essential to make an informed decision and consider whether to buy an extended warranty to cover additional costs. Different warranty companies may offer various types of warranties, including capped-price service or extended warranties on used cars. It's crucial to understand the terms and conditions of the warranty coverage to keep your warranty intact and get the best deal for your new vehicle.

When considering an extended warranty for a used car, it's essential to research the reputation of the warranty provider and the extended warranty coverage offered. Driva compares 30+ lenders so you get the best rate and ensures transparent and no hidden fees in the process. Additionally, factors such as the value of your vehicle and the cost of the warranty should be taken into account when purchasing an extended warranty. By choosing the right warranty provider, you can get the best deal and keep your car protected in case the warranty expires.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a dealership and a third-party service for extended warranties?

Dealerships typically provide extended warranties for new cars, while third-party providers offer warranties for both new and used vehicles.

How important is it to keep your warranty intact when considering vehicle service options?

It is crucial to follow the maintenance schedule outlined in your warranty to ensure it remains valid, whether you choose a dealership or a third-party service.

Why should I consider getting an extended auto warranty from a dealership?

Dealerships often provide warranties that are directly backed by the vehicle manufacturer, offering a sense of security and reliability.

Are third-party extended warranties a good option for covering vehicle service costs?

Third-party warranty providers can offer more flexibility and competitive pricing compared to dealership warranties, making them a viable alternative.

What is the difference between an authorised dealer and a third-party provider when it comes to extended vehicle warranties?

An authorised dealer offers warranties provided by the vehicle manufacturer, while third-party providers have their warranty programs that may differ in coverage and terms.

What are some key factors to consider when purchasing an extended car warranty?

It's essential to evaluate coverage options, cost, reputation of the provider, and whether you intend to keep the car for an extended period before deciding on a warranty.

Can I expect rental car reimbursement with both the dealership and third-party extended warranties?

Rental car reimbursement is a common feature in many extended warranties, but the specifics may vary between different warranty providers.

Philana Kwan

Philana Kwan is the marketing coordinator at Driva she has a demonstrated history in customer service excellence and is knowledgeable in all things car and finance related. When she’s not working Philana enjoys learning new things and keeping up with the latest trends in marketing and technology.

Find your best car loan in 60 secondsUse our free loan matching tool to assess your options.Start Now
Recent Posts

We search far and wide for your best rate, so you don’t have to!

Start Now
Find your perfect loan match in 60 seconds
Get your FREE quote